Appendix
A
Supplementary
Information on Distance Delivery
|
Traditional
Course |
Online
Course |
| Lectures |
Oral presentation, overhead
slides, handouts |
Text notes, slide show,
digital video clip examples, handouts |
| In
Class Discussion |
Instructor and student
interaction; student and student interaction |
Threaded discussion groups,
chatroom, email |
| Assessment |
Homework, quizzes, exams,
projects, participation |
Online homework and quizzes,
exams, projects, participation in threaded discussion |
| Group
Work |
Team communication via
in class discussion, email, phone, fax |
Team communication via
email, threaded discussion groups, chatroom, document sharing |
Research has shown
that distance delivery approaches are extremely successful for student
learning. Comparisons of student grades between students taking a course
face to face in a classroom with a teacher and students taking the same
course with the same teacher online via WWW demonstrate that the online
students perform on average 15-20% higher on final exams (Navarro, 1999;
Schutte, 1999). Specifically in interpreter education, the Educational
Interpreter Certificate Project was effective in significantly raising
interpreting students skill levels in a program that was primarily a distance
program. Students received some face-to-face skill courses during 3 week
summer sessions, but received intensive distance mentoring during two
full academic years. Using an assessment tool with a 5 point scale (based
on the EIPA), students' scores improved from pre-program averages of 2.0-2.8
to post-program averages of 3.4-3.7. A score of 3.5 was the goal for success
in this training program. (Johnson, 1999).
- Similarly, instructors for
the courses do not need to live in a specific geographical area nor
travel. This means that we can select instructors because of their expertise
and not convenience to our program. Because of this, the instructors
can be experts in a particular domain, have a regular full-time job,
and still teach a full semester-based course through our program.
- Enhanced interaction. Another
benefit of web-based courses is the very nature of the interaction.
All courses have a bulletin board where students can and must post questions
and comments about the course material, in a form of a threaded discussion
group. This means that a student can post a message about a specific
subject and when students respond, there messages are grouped with the
original one. Students can post at any time of the day; there are no
special times that everyone must meet. Due to the asynchronous interaction
and the medium (text), there is often more interaction from all students
than occurs in face-to-face courses and workshops. In addition, the
nature of the interactions is more prepared and well-thought-out, due
to the time students have to prepare before interacting. Additional
benefits are reported by distance students in web-based courses. Students
from a variety of ethnic and cultural backgrounds report that the interactions
feel more balanced and fair because immediate judgements based on appearance
are eliminated. This is also reported by students whose first language
is not English. Although many web courses are conducted in English,
students often report that the time for writing, revising, and proofreading
their input makes them more comfortable participating in these kinds
of classes. Students with various disabilities notice the lack of judgmental
attitudes from classmates and teachers. And, current technology has
made computer and internet access much easier for people with disabilities.
- Visual materials: We use
a great deal of signed examples in our courses, delivered via digital
movies on CD ROMs. In the course content, students can click on a hyperlink
to open a Quicktime movie. These movies are 30 frames per second, which
is real time motion, and the resolution is sufficient for fine-grained
analysis.
back to top
back to table of contents
|